menu click
Search

The Library

When is a gift not a donation?

When is a gift not a donation?
If an individual pays “…a monetary gift of $5 or more…” to a charity they are able to claim 1/3rd of it back from Inland Revenue (IRD). Prior to 1 April 2008, individuals could only claim donations of up to $1,890, i.e. a refund of $630.


The coalition Government at the time removed this limit and increased the threshold to the amount of taxable income, to incentivise individuals to give charitably. 

 

For the average New Zealander, limiting donation claims to the amount of a person’s taxable income is of no consequence. However, some high net worth individuals make donations that exceed the amount of their taxable income, thereby entitling them to large refunds. 

 

For example, a large donation could be made to help fund an important capital project of a charity, such as the construction of a new building for the homeless. The question then becomes how to structure a large donation, to ensure a donation rebate can be claimed. The problem lies in the legislation itself. Although the regime is to incentivise charitable giving, the legislation can be narrow in scope. The donation claim is restricted to monetary gifts made in an income year, whilst assets, such as “food” donated to the homeless, does not qualify for the tax credit. 

 

The High Court decision in Roberts v Commissioner of IR examined a donation rebate that was in the form of a loan forgiveness. Mrs Roberts had made a cash loan to a charity of $1.7m. The loan was subsequently being forgiven across multiple years and claimed as a donation rebate. IRD considered that a ‘debt forgiveness’ was not a charitable gift within the meaning of the current legislation because it was not a ‘cash’ gift. Judge Coleman decided in favour of Mrs Roberts and confirmed that a monetary gift did not require cash payment, provided that it was a gift of a specific sum and was not a chattel or property item. Judgement was upheld for Mrs Roberts. 

 

The forgiveness approach is no different, for example, to Mrs Roberts making the loan and then making cash donations in future years that are used by the charity to repay her loan. In substance, cash has been paid by a private individual to a charity – being the purpose of the regime. In a surprise move, when the Taxation (Annual rates for 2018-19, Modernising Tax Administration, and Remedial Matters) Bill was reported back from the Finance and Expenditure committee (FEC) on 18 January, IRD had included a recommendation that the current legislation be amended to prescribe that donations need to comprise a “gift of money”, thereby legislating against the decision in Roberts. By recommending the change at such a late stage of the enactment process, it skips the public consultation phase. IRD have justified the change by asserting that the 2007 rewrite of the Income Tax Act changed the meaning, and they are merely changing it back. 

 

Rather than accepting IRD’s view, it would been nice if the FEC had looked at the issue more ‘charitably’.

Share

Post a Comment



  • Improve your niche marketing strategy

    A niche marketing strategy is one that targets a specific subset of a market and is not a strategy that is ideal for every business.
  • Tax pooling

    Inland Revenue (IRD) charges a high rate of interest on late tax payments (currently 8.22%), and in some circumstances the complexity of the provisional tax regime makes interest charges hard to avoid...
  • Familiarise yourself with the bright-line test criteria

    The bright-line test is a system the IRD uses to determine whether income received from the sale of residential land will be taxed. This process has undergone changes to become more expensive, meani...
  • Tax Working Group

    The Tax Working Group (TWG) released its long awaited Final Report (‘the Report’) on 21 February 2019, following a 13 month review during which the Group received over 7,000 public submissions. The ...